The Designer's Dilemma: Navigating Job Offers and Design Exercises
Written on
Chapter 1: The Emotional Landscape of Job Offers
When contemplating a job offer in design, it's common to feel a mix of excitement and apprehension—especially for those stepping into their first role or returning after a hiatus. Many designers recognize the importance of showcasing their skills and demonstrating their value to the team; this is simply part of the professional journey.
Section 1.1: The Hiring Process
Finding the ideal candidate can be a daunting task for both designers and hiring managers. Managers are tasked with identifying the best fit for the role, which necessitates considerable effort and commitment.
Subsection 1.1.1: Understanding Designer Thought Processes
To tackle the complexities of hiring, managers often implement several stages in the selection process. A key component in hiring designers is assessing their approach to problem-solving. Observing how a designer deconstructs intricate user or business challenges can provide significant insights into their work style.
Section 1.2: The Design Assignment Conundrum
Companies frequently refer to this evaluation as a Design Assignment or a take-home exercise. Designers are expected to address a given problem and present their solutions within a specified timeframe.
What Designers Experience
This selection method often induces anxiety and self-doubt among designers. The design assignment represents a pivotal opportunity to stand out in the hiring process, yet many designers fear the stakes involved.
Expectations for Design Assignments
Designers are anticipated to deliver solutions that align closely with the interviewers' expectations—though this may not always be a fair assessment.
The Challenge of Real Work Problems
Unfortunately, design challenges increasingly resemble requests to "Redesign our homepage" or "Revamp our checkout process with justification." Instead, companies might consider asking broader questions, such as, "What should be prioritized when designing a company website?" or "Can you create wireframes or conduct research to support your design choices?"
Chapter 2: The Burden of Unpaid Work
Designers often receive feedback on their submissions for these assignments, which can be due within just 24 hours. As the scope of the project expands, the likelihood of successfully passing this round diminishes.
Creating a design case study is no small feat; it demands research, design expertise, narrative skills, and a grasp of user experience and psychology. Regrettably, many companies expect managers to accomplish this work for free and under tight deadlines.
Ethics in Hiring
Companies should prioritize the candidate experience rather than relying on designers to tackle all their design challenges as part of the hiring process.
The Reality of Work Expectations
Recruiters often suggest that the effort you invest now will pay off later. However, grinding away at your current job for minimal raises can seem less rewarding than the potential to earn significantly more through multiple interviews, which can require extensive unpaid work.
Ultimately, the outcome is uncertain. It is advisable to steer clear of take-home tests and repetitive assessments. Instead, consider engaging in direct discussions and collaborative whiteboarding sessions.
Section 2.1: Evaluating Candidates with Whiteboard Challenges
Whiteboard challenges are another method used to assess candidates during in-person interviews. These involve scenarios or problems that candidates must solve on a whiteboard or similar medium.
The Value of Whiteboard Challenges
These challenges aim to quickly gauge a candidate's skills in interaction design and teamwork. They offer hiring managers insights into a candidate's ability to think on their feet and adapt to various situations, ultimately providing a clearer picture of their suitability for the role.
Share your experiences and insights on navigating these challenges!