Exploring Adam Smith's Moral Sentiments and the Invisible Hand
Written on
Chapter 1: The Intersection of Interests
The world of business reveals a significant overlap between the interests of the public and those of private entities.
Francis Hutcheson, an Irish philosopher and a pivotal figure in the Scottish Enlightenment, authored A System of Moral Philosophy. His thoughts profoundly influenced prominent Enlightenment figures, including Adam Smith and David Hume. Hutcheson, like Smith, recognized the alignment of public and private interests but attributed this to personal intuition, which he termed a “moral sense.” In contrast, Smith proposed a model where six psychological motivations converge in individuals to foster the common good.
In The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Adam Smith asserts:
“By acting according to the dictates of our moral faculties, we necessarily pursue the most effective means for promoting the happiness of mankind.” (Vol. II, p. 316)
It is a common misconception that Smith believed all self-serving actions inherently benefit society, or that public goods arise solely from self-interest. His argument suggests that, within a free market, individuals tend to create products that are desired by those around them. An instance of self-interest leading to negative outcomes is illustrated by the tragedy of the commons.
The concept of the "invisible hand" is typically associated with economics, but it also appears in various academic fields under different terminologies, such as Darwinian natural selection. This pattern language can be applied across diverse topics, including consciousness and free will. Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph E. Stiglitz comments:
“The reason that the invisible hand often seems invisible is that it is often not there.”
Stiglitz elucidates his viewpoint:
Adam Smith, regarded as the father of modern economics, is frequently referenced for his advocacy of the "invisible hand" and free markets, suggesting that businesses, in their quest for profits, are guided—much like by an invisible hand—to act in the best interest of society. However, unlike his followers, Smith acknowledged some limitations of free markets. Research conducted since his time has clarified why free markets alone often fail to achieve optimal outcomes. Stiglitz states, “As I put it in my new book, Making Globalization Work, the reason that the invisible hand often seems invisible is that it is often not there.”
When externalities arise—where an individual's actions affect others without compensation—market efficiency declines. Environmental externalities are a well-known example. Markets can produce excessive pollution and insufficient funding for essential research. The government has historically funded many significant scientific advancements, including the internet and initial telegraph communications.
Recent studies have shown that such externalities are widespread, particularly in the presence of imperfect information or risk. Government intervention is crucial in areas like banking and securities regulation, as certain regulations are necessary for market functionality. Most would agree that government is essential for upholding contracts and property rights. The ongoing debate revolves around finding an optimal balance between market forces and government intervention, alongside the contributions of non-profit organizations. This equilibrium varies across different contexts and times.
The Key Insight
Regardless of his intentions, the concept of the “invisible hand” stands as a cornerstone of economic theory. Adam Smith suggested that competitive markets efficiently allocate resources. The 2009 financial crisis has intensified discussions about the appropriate relationship between markets and government, prompting some scholars to re-evaluate whether the conditions that Smith described still hold relevance in today's global economic landscape.
Chapter 2: Theoretical Foundations
The first video, The Essential Adam Smith: Moral Sentiments, delves into the fundamental aspects of Smith's theories, exploring how his ideas still resonate in modern discussions about morality and economics.
The second video, Adam Smith, Theory of Moral Sentiments, provides an overview of Smith's work, illustrating how his insights into moral philosophy continue to inform contemporary thought.
This narrative is an excerpt from my course “How to Become Really Wealthy,” part of my Personal Growth series of affordable self-guided courses.
An Introduction to My New Course "How to Become Really Wealthy".
Part of my Personal Growth Series of Inexpensive Self-Guided Courses
asklewis.substack.com
©Lewis Harrison, all rights reserved. Here are a few stories in a similar vein
@LewisCoaches
The 7 Worst Secrets of Misinformation
How to read through the nonsense
@robin_wilding
Do You Secretly Have Crab People In Your Life?
There are crab-in-a-bucket people who secretly live among us