Choosing Between Mac Studio and MacBook Pro: 5 Key Questions
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Your Needs
In today's world, the introduction of the M1 chip has transformed the landscape for Mac users, making it possible for everyone to find a device that fits their budget without compromising on performance. Whether you opt for the entry-level M1 or the high-end M1 Ultra, you can expect exceptional performance tailored to your needs. The real risk lies in not choosing the specifications that match your usage requirements.
I've often seen comments on my YouTube channel where users express uncertainty about which model to choose. For example, they might say, "I'm considering the 16GB M1 chip for my video editing and Photoshop work, but I'm concerned the 8GB version won't suffice." My advice is straightforward: invest as much as you can afford to avoid regret later. Regardless of your choice, the performance will likely surpass your expectations.
But what happens when you're faced with the decision between the MacBook Pro and the new Mac Studio? Here are five simple questions to guide your choice.
Section 1.1: What's Your Budget?
Your dilemma may stem from budget considerations, as the base 14-inch MacBook Pro and the entry-level Mac Studio are priced similarly at $1,999 (unless you’re in the UK, where the MacBook Pro starts at £1,899 for reasons unclear). If you decide to upgrade either model, you could easily exceed $6,000.
This price point might lead you to believe that both devices are comparable. However, a significant distinction exists: the MacBook Pro comes with a display, keyboard, and trackpad, while the Mac Studio only includes a power cable. This difference greatly impacts your decision, making the next question unavoidable.
But first, establish a budget that feels right for you. Write it down, embrace that figure, and move forward.
Section 1.2: Do You Require High Multi-Core Performance?
A common theme across Mac Studio reviews, including my own, is that very few users truly need the immense capabilities of the M1 Ultra chip. This is a critical consideration for your decision. If you plan to edit multiple streams of 8K video or engage in extensive audio production where time is crucial, the M1 Ultra may be necessary.
In that case, the Mac Studio is your best option. However, I can confidently say that most potential buyers likely don't require the extreme power the M1 Ultra provides. If you’re still reading, let’s continue.
Subsection 1.2.1: How Important is Portability to You?
I recently pointed out that the 16-inch MacBook Pro can be cumbersome to carry daily due to its size and weight. In contrast, the 14-inch MacBook Pro is highly portable, fitting comfortably on nearly any desk and easily transportable under your arm.
While the Mac Studio has a compact design, it isn't particularly mobile. You might find it easy to relocate, but taking it to a coffee shop isn't practical. I bought my 16-inch MacBook Pro before the Mac Studio was released, yet I would still choose it today for its versatility. Being able to edit videos in various locations is essential for my workflow.
So, consider whether you can manage with a powerful Mac stationed in one place or if you require one that can move with you.
Section 1.3: How Much Do You Value a Retina Display?
As previously mentioned, the Mac Studio lacks built-in peripherals. To use it, you’ll need a keyboard, mouse or trackpad, and a display. While peripherals shouldn’t heavily influence your decision, the display is another matter.
If you’re accustomed to a Retina display on devices like the iMac, MacBook, iPad, or iPhone, and you want that experience with your new Mac, you have two choices: purchase the MacBook Pro for its Liquid Retina XDR ProMotion display, or acquire a Mac Studio along with a Studio Display.
Keep in mind that the latter option will set you back an additional $1,599. The Studio Display has faced criticism since its launch, but if you’re seeking a large display with 5K resolution and impressive pixel density without resorting to the Pro Display XDR, it’s your only choice.
Be aware that opting for the Mac Studio and a 4K monitor may not deliver the visual quality you're used to, which could be disappointing. This brings us back to your budget: can you justify the extra cost for a Retina display, or does the MacBook Pro offer better value?
Section 1.4: Are Alternatives Worth Considering?
It’s important to reiterate what I mentioned earlier: every Mac, from the basic M1 to the top-tier M1 Ultra, provides excellent performance for its intended purpose. Apple’s silicon has revolutionized computing power for Mac users. Even if I didn’t have my M1 Max 16-inch MacBook Pro, I could comfortably edit 4K YouTube videos on the M1 Mac mini or even the entry-level M1 MacBook Air if necessary.
While you may be focused on the MacBook Pro or Mac Studio, you might save significant money by considering alternatives like the Mac mini, 24-inch iMac, or MacBook Air. Before finalizing your purchase, take a moment to explore these options.
Wrap Up
If I’ve done my job correctly, you should now have a clearer understanding of whether a notebook or desktop Mac suits your needs. With this information in mind, return to your budget and put it to good use. Remember to customize your new Mac to a level that feels comfortable for you, and when you hit that 'buy now' button, you can do so confidently, avoiding any buyer’s remorse when your new device arrives.
Enjoy your new Mac!
Before You Go
If you appreciate my writing, know that there's more to discover on Medium. I’m a paid member myself and highly recommend joining. Click here to join (a portion of your membership fee supports my work!).
This video compares the MacBook Pro and Mac Studio, helping you understand which is right for your needs.
In this video, I explain why I chose to buy the Mac Studio, providing insights into its advantages.