# 5 Films That Surpass Their Literary Counterparts
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction
Years ago, I established a personal guideline: choose to either read the book or watch the film, but avoid doing both. Although I've strayed from this rule numerous times, my approach is often reversed. Instead of reading the book first, I typically watch the movie and then delve into the book to uncover more details. It's a common belief that the book usually surpasses the film, largely because it presents the creator's original, unfiltered vision without Hollywood's interference.
Nonetheless, we must acknowledge the power of collaboration. When the right people unite on a project, the outcome can exceed expectations. While reading a book engages the imagination, sometimes a film can convey certain elements more effectively than we could envision. Here, we explore five films that managed to achieve this remarkable feat, in no particular order. Spoilers will follow, but if you've seen the films, they shouldn't matter much.
Section 1.1: The Shining
Stephen King might not appreciate my inclusion of this film, as he has voiced strong disapproval of Stanley Kubrick's adaptation. He argues that the relationships in the film lack depth, which is a valid critique. King's talent lies in crafting intricate characters and relationships. However, the film captivates audiences because it showcases Kubrick's directorial genius. Though both the book and the movie are chilling and surreal, the film leaves a more profound impact.
Section 1.2: Blade Runner
Philip K. Dick's original title, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, may not attract much attention. Thankfully, the film Blade Runner offers a more appealing name and a masterful cinematic experience. Ridley Scott expertly adapts Dick's thought-provoking ideas, enveloping them in a rich atmosphere and compelling visuals. While both the book and film share a captivating world, the film enhances the narrative with its haunting score. The ambiguity of the protagonist Deckard's identity is explored more effectively on screen, making the film a lasting impression.
Subsection 1.2.1: A Clockwork Orange
Kubrick strikes again, but for different reasons this time. The novel A Clockwork Orange presents its own set of challenges with its unique language, Nadsat, which can be difficult for readers. The film, however, immerses viewers in the story and allows for a more straightforward understanding of the characters. While the film remains faithful to the book, its exploration of morality raises thought-provoking questions that the book ultimately undermines in its conclusion. The movie's ending provides a more satisfying and darker resolution.
Section 1.3: The Godfather
Many are surprised to discover that The Godfather originated as a novel, which was a gripping read in its own right. The film remains mostly true to the book while excising unnecessary details. There are aspects of the novel, such as a subplot involving Mrs. Corleone's prayers for her husband, that would have added depth to the film. However, the movie's stunning performances and atmospheric storytelling have ensured its place in cultural history, overshadowing the book.
Chapter 2: The Princess Bride
Similar to The Godfather, The Princess Bride trims the excess while staying loyal to the source material. Readers may be surprised at how much of the original dialogue made it into the film. The book opens with author William Goldman on a fictional quest for a copy of S. Morgenstern's tale to read to his son, a detail that is streamlined in the movie. Despite this, the book is a delightful read, brimming with charm, though it lacks the film's iconic cast.
The first video, "10 Movies That Are Better Than The Book," explores various adaptations that have outshone their literary counterparts, delving into the elements that make them stand out.
The second video, "Movies That Were Better Than the Book," further analyzes the differences between books and their film adaptations, highlighting key examples.
In conclusion, the interplay between books and their film adaptations can yield surprising outcomes. While the original text often has its merits, these films demonstrate that, under the right circumstances, a cinematic interpretation can transcend its source material. Thank you for reading! If you found this discussion valuable, please feel free to engage by clapping, commenting, or subscribing.