Navigating the Unique Challenges of Product Management in AgTech
Written on
Chapter 1: The Rise of Modern AgTech
The inception of the contemporary AgTech sector can be traced to the early 2000s, a period marked by rapid digital advancements and growing challenges within agriculture.
Since that time, the AgTech industry has undergone significant waves of innovation. The demand for specialized product management roles to create and oversee innovative agricultural solutions has surged. Examples of these solutions include farm management software, precision agriculture tools, IoT devices, and remote sensing technologies.
At present, many organizations within the AgTech realm adopt a product-led approach. However, product managers in this field encounter challenges that are distinct to the AgTech sector. Having spent time in Product Management within AgTech, I’d like to highlight the primary challenges faced by Product Managers in this domain.
If you're considering a transition into AgTech, prepare to address some of the most pressing issues of our time: sustainably feeding the world's growing population while navigating unique challenges.
Let’s delve into these challenges.
Chapter 2: Understanding Agronomy
An experience I had exemplifies this challenge. A new algorithm was launched as part of a feature in Europe. While discussing a possible release in South America, a colleague pointed out: “The field trials for the new algorithm were conducted in Europe; the grass in Brazil differs!”
Ultimately, we could not launch the feature in Brazil due to the significant differences in grass types.
To illustrate further, consider:
- A winter wheat crop (12% protein) cultivated on sandy soil with nutrient values of P = 5 mg/100 g, K = 9 mg/100 g, Mg = 4.6 mg/100 g, pH = 5.8
- Versus a winter wheat crop (11% protein) on slightly loamy sand soil with nutrient values of P = 6 mg/100 g, K = 11 mg/100 g, Mg = 6.6 mg/100 g, pH = 6
This brings us to our first challenge: Understanding Agronomy.
Agronomy is a branch of agricultural science focused on crop and soil management. It examines the interactions between crops, soils, and the environment to ensure sustainable productivity. Agronomists aim to enhance agricultural efficiency, food security, and promote sustainable practices through research and field trials.
As a PM in AgTech, while a formal agronomic background isn’t mandatory, grasping basic agronomy is crucial. You should recognize the complex variations that exist and ensure that the digital farming tools developed can adapt to numerous factors to provide accurate insights.
So, how can PMs navigate this challenge?
- Conduct data analysis: Agronomic data is available; your goal is to identify and analyze relevant parameters for your tool.
- Engage with agronomists.
- Visit farms to interact with farmers.
Chapter 3: The Slow and Seasonal Nature of Agriculture
The agricultural sector is inherently slow-moving and highly seasonal due to the growth cycles of crops.
For example:
- A maize crop typically takes between 60 and 100 days from sowing to harvest.
- Wheat and rice can take approximately 90 to 150 days, depending on various factors.
Unlike rapid-tech industries, the AgTech sector operates in sync with the agricultural calendar, resulting in a slower pace of progress.
So, what implications does this have for PMs in AgTech?
The development and launch of products must align with crop cycles, factoring in planting and harvesting seasons. As a PM, understanding the agricultural calendar globally is essential to ensure timely technology deployment.
For instance, launching a planting recommendation feature during planting season can disrupt operations, while a fertilizer recommendation tool introduced late into the season offers no value.
PMs must also be prepared for prolonged feedback cycles. For a fertilizer recommendation tool launched at the start of the season, feedback may only arrive post-harvest, potentially five months later. This contrasts sharply with rapid feedback in other tech sectors.
To navigate this challenge:
- Familiarize yourself with global crop calendars and incorporate them into your launch strategies.
- Collaborate closely with farmers and gather substantial user feedback pre-launch.
- Conduct extensive testing and validation before finalizing features.
Chapter 4: Transforming Tradition
Agriculture is steeped in tradition, often leading to resistance against rapid changes. Older generations of farmers may be particularly hesitant to adopt new technologies.
One farmer once remarked, “Why should I use crop monitoring tools? If I need satellite imagery to monitor my fields, then I’m in the wrong business!”
Thus, as a PM in AgTech, it’s vital to acknowledge this reality and prepare for longer adoption cycles. Building trust, showcasing clear benefits, and providing comprehensive support and training are essential for encouraging farmers to embrace new technologies.
How can PMs effectively manage this challenge?
- Avoid “over-innovation” to ensure farmers remain engaged.
- Focus on straightforward, impactful tools that cater to the complexities of farming.
- Recognize the differences between older and younger farmers; younger generations tend to be more open to digital solutions.
Chapter 5: Catering to a Diverse User Base
The AgTech user base is incredibly varied, ranging from smallholder farmers in developing nations to large-scale operations in developed countries.
Consider the average farm sizes:
- Indonesia: 0.5 - 2 hectares (1.2 - 4.9 acres)
- France: 55 hectares (135 acres)
- Australia: 3,340 hectares (8,250 acres)
The disparity in farm sizes leads to differing needs and challenges. Smallholder farmers often focus on market access, while larger farms prioritize operational efficiency and supply chain management.
Moreover, varying regional regulations can significantly impact the development of precision farming tools, such as fertilizer and pesticide recommendations.
As a PM, you must assess the unique needs of this diverse user base while recognizing that a “one-size-fits-all” solution is impractical.
Navigating this challenge involves:
- Conducting detailed market and customer research.
- Performing a segment analysis.
- Developing solutions tailored to user groups’ specific needs.
Conclusion
Overall, product management in the AgTech industry presents unique challenges due to the sector's complexity and diversity. Successfully navigating these challenges requires a comprehensive understanding of global agriculture, adaptable digital tools, patience in a slow-moving sector, and effective strategies for transformation.
By considering these factors, working in product management within the AgTech space can be immensely fulfilling. As a PM, you have the opportunity to drive innovation, contribute to sustainable advancements, and play a crucial role in empowering farmers and reshaping agricultural practices in the 21st century.
If you’ve made it this far, thank you for reading! Feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn for further discussions.
Chapter 6: The Growth, Challenges, and Opportunities of AgTech
This video discusses the evolution of AgTech, highlighting the growth, challenges, and opportunities within the sector.